Continue to site >
Trending ETFs

Is Options Upside Becoming Capped?

The pitch is familiar: sell someone else optionality, collect the premium, repeat monthly. Covered call writing and cash-secured put selling are functionally the same trade wearing different clothes — put-call parity guarantees that a covered call and a cash-secured put at the same strike and expiration produce near-identical payoffs, net of dividends and financing. Both monetize the same structural feature of the options market: implied volatility’s tendency to price above subsequently realized volatility, a spread academics call the volatility risk premium. Premium sellers harvest that spread systematically, month after month, in exchange for giving up some or all of the underlying’s upside.

That harvest is currently priced at a middling level. The VIX closed at 20.66 on July 29, up 13.45% in a single session from 18.21 the prior close, after spending most of the preceding month range-bound between roughly 15 and 21 with an average close to 17 . That’s not a crisis reading, but it sits above the complacent high-single-digit and low-teens prints that punctuated large stretches of 2024 and early 2025 — one-month at-the-money SPX premium is somewhat richer than the summer lull, without yet reflecting the kind of dislocation that makes premium selling genuinely lucrative.

What the benchmarks actually show

Cboe maintains two live, rules-based benchmarks that make this trade-off precise rather than anecdotal: the S&P 500 BuyWrite Index (BXM), which sells at-the-money monthly SPX calls against a long S&P 500 position, and the S&P 500 PutWrite Index (PUT), which sells at-the-money monthly SPX puts collateralized by Treasury bills. Both have multi-decade live histories, not backtests dressed up as track records.

Since BXM’s first value date of June 20, 1986, the index has compounded at 8.5% annualized versus 11.2% for the S&P 500 total return index — a real return gap of roughly 270 basis points a year. But it got there with annualized volatility of 10.7% against the index’s 15.2%, a maximum drawdown of -35.8% versus -50.9%, and a beta of 0.62. PUT, with a history dating to January 2007, tells a similar story: 7.0% annualized versus 11.0% for the S&P 500, volatility of 10.8% versus 15.5%, and a shallower -32.7% maximum drawdown against the S&P 500’s -50.9%. Sharpe ratios land close to even (0.55 BXM versus 0.56 S&P 500 since 1989; 0.51 PUT versus 0.61 S&P 500 since 2007), while Sortino ratios — penalizing only downside deviation — favor the S&P 500, since premium selling forfeits the upside convexity that flatters a raw long position’s Sortino. A narrower academic sample from Callan Associates, covering 1988 through 2006, found BXM’s Sharpe ratio nearly double the S&P 500’s — 0.52 versus 0.30 — at about two-thirds the volatility. The precise numbers shift with the sample window, but the shape — lower volatility for a return give-up smaller than intuition suggests — has held up across studies and cycles.

Roni Israelov and Lars Nielsen’s 2015 Financial Analysts Journal paper decomposed BXM’s return into three exposures: equity market beta, which drives most of its risk and return; short volatility, carrying a realized Sharpe ratio near 1.0 historically but under 10% of total risk; and an uncompensated equity-reversal exposure baked into the monthly rebalance, responsible for roughly a quarter of the strategy’s risk for little reward. That is the honest verdict: covered calls are not a free lunch. They repackage equity risk plus a modest, real, but not enormous volatility-selling edge, diluted by inefficiency in how systematic benchmarks roll their options.

The bull-market tax

The opportunity cost shows up cleanly in calendar-year data. In 2023 the S&P 500 total return index returned 26.3% while BXM captured 11.8% and PUT captured 14.3%. In 2024 the index returned 25.0% against BXM’s 20.1% and PUT’s 17.8%. In 2025 the S&P returned 17.9% versus BXM’s 8.9% and PUT’s 9.2%. Three consecutive years of mega-cap-driven upside left both strategies giving back 8 to 18 percentage points of annual return apiece — capped calls cannot keep pace when a handful of names carry the tape. Retail covered call ETFs show the same dynamic: JEPI currently yields roughly 8.2% to 8.4% on a trailing basis, an attractive income stream earned partly by sacrificing the AI-led upside that has driven index returns. Higher-yielding, more mechanical products like QYLD, which prints an 11%-plus distribution yield selling calls on the Nasdaq-100, have shown meaningful NAV erosion over time — on the order of 3.7% annualized — a reminder that headline yield is not total return.

Execution mechanics that actually matter

Strike selection is the main lever available to a trader deviating from benchmark construction. At-the-money strikes maximize premium and downside cushion but cap upside almost entirely; strikes 5% to 10% out-of-the-money concede more upside for less premium. Since the benchmark studies above use at-the-money construction, a real-world OTM implementation should expect both a smaller return drag and a smaller volatility reduction than the index-level numbers imply. Expiration choice trades theta efficiency against gamma risk: weeklies harvest decay faster on an annualized basis but demand more active strike management per roll, and assignment risk concentrates around ex-dividend dates for covered calls and rises for cash-secured puts as spot approaches the strike into expiration.

Tax treatment diverges sharply depending on the underlying instrument. Covered calls and cash-secured puts written on individual equities or SPY are taxed under ordinary short-term and long-term capital gains rules, and a covered call that fails to meet the IRS definition of a “qualified covered call” can toll the underlying stock’s holding period or trigger straddle loss-deferral rules under Internal Revenue Code Section 1092. Selling calls or puts on SPX itself, by contrast, qualifies for Section 1256 treatment: a mandatory 60% long-term, 40% short-term blend regardless of holding period, marked to market at year-end — a meaningful after-tax edge for high-bracket investors, and one reason index-option and equity-option premium selling are not tax-equivalent even when payoff diagrams look identical.

For most sophisticated investors, the question isn’t whether these strategies “work” — the multi-decade data says they modestly do, on a risk-adjusted basis, across most measured periods — but whether the specific strike, expiration, and vehicle match the tax situation, and whether the investor has made peace with the honest expectation that upside will be capped precisely in the years it matters most.