Continue to site >
Trending ETFs

Should You Lengthen Your Bond Ladder Now? How to Decide When Yields Are Near Multi-Decade Highs

For most of the past 15 years, building a bond ladder meant accepting low yields on the short rungs and only slightly better yields on the long ones. That’s changed. In early October, the 10-year Treasury yield hit 5.35%, its highest level since 2002. It has eased since, falling to about 4.89% after the midterm elections, but it’s still higher than at almost any point since before the 2008 financial crisis. The 30-year sits near 5.3%.

That raises a question many ladder investors are now asking. Should a ladder that runs out five years be stretched to 10 or more to lock in these yields while they last?

There’s no single right answer, but there is a clear way to think about it.

Start with what lengthening actually does. A ladder spreads money across bonds that mature at regular intervals, say one through five years. Each year, a rung matures and the money is reinvested at the long end. Extending the ladder to 10 years means adding rungs from six through 10 years. That locks in today’s yields for a longer stretch and reduces how much money needs to be reinvested each year at whatever rates prevail in the future.

The benefit is protection against falling rates. If yields drop over the next few years, a five-year ladder will be reinvesting at lower rates much sooner than a 10-year ladder. Someone who built a long ladder of Treasuries at 5% in 2007 kept collecting those yields through years when new bonds paid 2%.

The cost is exposure to rising rates and inflation. If yields keep climbing, a longer ladder holds more bonds that pay less than new issues, and their market values drop further. If the bonds are held to maturity, that loss only matters for anyone who needs to sell early. But it also means the ladder is reinvesting less money each year at the new, higher rates.

Right now, the yield curve offers more reward for extending than it has in years. For much of 2023 and 2024, short-term Treasury bills paid more than 10-year notes, so there was no reason to go long. Today, the curve has a normal shape again. Bills pay a little under 4%, the 2-year sits around 4.5%, and the 10-year is close to 4.9%. Each extra year of maturity pays something more. The pickup isn’t huge between five and 10 years, but it’s there.

Here’s how to decide whether lengthening makes sense for a particular ladder.

The first question is what the ladder is for. If it funds specific expenses, like living costs in the first decade of retirement, the ladder should match those dates. A retiree who needs $40,000 a year from the portfolio for the next 10 years has a natural reason to own bonds maturing in each of those years. Lengthening to match that need isn’t a rate bet. It’s matching assets to spending.

The second question is how much the investor cares about reinvestment risk versus price risk. A shorter ladder keeps more flexibility and more exposure to future rates, for better or worse. A longer ladder locks in more certainty. Investors who would be upset if rates fell and their income dropped should lean longer. Those who would rather keep options open in case rates go higher should stay shorter.

The third question is inflation. A longer ladder of nominal bonds is a bet that inflation won’t erode the fixed payments too much. With oil swinging between $90 and $120 this year and the Fed still debating another hike, that’s a real risk. Investors worried about inflation can split the difference by using TIPS for the longer rungs. TIPS yields are also near the highest levels in years, and they adjust principal for inflation.

There’s also a middle path. Instead of extending the whole ladder at once, investors can lengthen gradually. As each short rung matures, the proceeds can go to the new long end of a 10-year ladder rather than a five-year one. Over several years, the ladder stretches out without committing all the money at today’s rates. This reduces the risk of locking in just before yields rise further.

Another approach is to extend only part of the portfolio. Someone with a five-year ladder could add a few longer rungs, say at seven and 10 years, without reshaping the whole structure. That captures some of today’s long yields while keeping most of the money on a shorter schedule.

A couple of practical points matter when extending.

Callable bonds are a bigger issue on longer rungs. Many corporate and municipal bonds can be redeemed early by the issuer, and they’re most likely to be called exactly when rates fall, which is when the investor wanted to keep them. For long rungs, non-callable Treasuries, TIPS or bullet corporate bonds are usually the better choice.

Target-maturity ETFs make extending easier. These funds hold a diversified basket of bonds that all mature in the same year, then return their assets to shareholders. They’re available for Treasuries, corporate bonds, munis and TIPS with maturities through the mid-2030s, often for expense ratios around 0.10%. Adding a 2033 or 2035 rung is as simple as buying a single ETF.

The election rally pushed yields down from their October peak, and some of the best entry points may already be gone. But yields near 4.9% on the 10-year are still well above the average of the last 15 years. For investors whose ladder is meant to fund a long horizon, extending some of it at these levels is a reasonable move, as long as it’s done for the right reasons and not as a guess about where rates go next.